Top Boston Red Sox Players Likely to Make the 2025 All-Star Team

Christopher Boan Profile Picture
Fact Checked by Thomas Leary

After a rocky start to the regular season, it’s worth wondering which members of the Boston Red Sox organization will represent the club at next month’s MLB All-Star Game, which takes place in Atlanta this year. With that in mind, BetMassachusetts.com broke down the odds on which Sox players will take the field down south come July 15.  

Red Sox All-Star Odds 2025

Player 

Position 

Odds 

Percent Chance 

Garrett Crochet 

Starting Pitcher 

-1250 

92.6% 

Rafael Devers 

Designated Hitter 

-375 

78.9% 

Aroldis Chapman 

Relief Pitcher 

+110 

47.6% 

Carlos Narvaez 

Catcher 

+275 

26.7% 

Stick with BetMass for the top Sox futures bets at Massachusetts sportsbooks

Must be 21+. MA Only. Subject to eligibility requirements. Bonus bets are non-withdrawable. In Partnership with MGM Springfield.
 MA PG Hotline LogoHope is here. Call (800) 327-5050 or http://gamblinghelplinema.org
Gamesense Logo Play it smart from the start! Live Chat @ http://GameSenseMA.com

Who Makes MLB All-Star Game From Boston?

Garrett Crochet -1250

While the Red Sox have limped through a 34-36 season to date, there have been a slew of silver linings in Beantown, with southpaw Garrett Crochet being among the best starting pitchers in baseball this season. The fifth year veteran has a team-high 2.5 WAR (per Baseball-Reference.com) this season, going 6-4 on the bump with an ERA of 2.35 in 14 starts for the Red Sox, putting him in line to be on the AL staff come July 15. That’s why we have the 26-year-old at -1250 to make the AL team, joining DH Rafael Devers as the only Boston players with greater than 50% odds of making the Mid-Summer Classic, as Devers comes in at -375 to make the club in 2025.  

Devers, Chapman Have Work To Do

To date, Devers has the highest WAR total of any Red Sox position player, at 2.4, bashing 14 home runs and hitting .280 with 71 hits this season, putting him in line to potentially make his fourth All-Star Game appearance.  

Other potential candidates to represent the Junior Circuit come July 15 from Boston include reliver Aroldis Chapman, who is listed at +110 to potentially make his eighth ASG appearance, while catcher Carlos Narvaez rounds out the Red Sox ASG list, at +275.  

For now, all four are looking to help guide Boston back to the postseason for the first time since 2021, with oddsmakers from FanDuel Massachusetts currently giving the club +295 odds of making the field come the fall.  

USA Today photo by Brad Penner.

Q&A: 2025 Red Sox All-Star Game Projections

21+ and present in MA. T&Cs apply.
 MA PG Hotline LogoHope is here. Call (800) 327-5050 or http://gamblinghelplinema.org
Gamesense Logo Play it smart from the start! Live Chat @ http://GameSenseMA.com

Author

Christopher Boan

Christopher Boan has been covering sports and sports betting for more than seven years, including stops at ArizonaSports.com, the Tucson Weekly and the Green Valley News.

Cited by leading media organizations, such as: